« Reality Is Subjective: Theory Confirmed | Main | Live. Err. Forget. Repeat. »

May 11, 2007

Congenital Liar

O
ne of my all-time favorite columns by William Safire was the one in which called Hillary Clinton a "congenital liar." Not that I agreed. I just enjoyed the word play.

Okay. So today Veep Cheney was on an aircraft carrier projecting America's power at Iran again. [It was the USS John C. Stennis -- who's worth about five posts all by himself.]

Reading Cheney's ballast (as in "load") made me long for Safire . . . and another column about someone who's really a congenital liar.

Update: A commenter quotes one of the definitions for ballast from the Oxford English Dictionary as: "3. That which tends to give stability in morals or politics..." Then the commenter asks if I was actually stating the truth. The answer is "no," I was correct in my intentionally ironic use of the word ballast which, while it can mean what the commenter said, also means -- according to Webster's Third International Dictionary -- "roughage," a particularly useful ingredient for making bullshit.


Update: Thank you for the spelling corrections.
Update II: "Ballast." No spell check on this sight.


Posted by shertaugh at May 11, 2007 5:43 PM

Comments

I don't get it. "Congential" is not, as far as I can tell, a word, yet you use it twice. Safire does not; he uses "congenital," so "congential" appears to be merely a typo. But where is the word play in "congenital liar"? "Congenital" means "acquired at birth," so Safire doesn't mean it literally, but "congenital liar" is a common metaphor for someone who lies repeatedly. Again, where is the word play?

Posted by: Henry at May 11, 2007 9:29 PM

I thought Bill was the one who lied about his genitals.

Posted by: Kevin at May 12, 2007 11:07 AM

Great. Only took me ten years to get the pun.

Posted by: Syd Henderson at May 14, 2007 1:05 PM

What is "balast"? I can't figure out what that's supposed to be, either. Blast?

Posted by: Dave S. at May 14, 2007 3:09 PM

Ballast. That's an interesting choice of words. From the Oxford English Dictionary: "ballast: 3. That which tends to give stability in morals or politics..." How does that square with your accusation of congenital lying? Perhaps you wrote the truth without realizing it, eh?

Posted by: Dave S. at May 16, 2007 1:45 PM

To clariy my comment, I was not asking if you wrote the truth, but suggesting that you did. The question was rhetorical. In other words, while you would use the word ballast to characterize Cheney's comments as "roughage" I would use the same word to characterize them as lending stability and reason to the political discourse. Of course we disagree--no surprise there-- but I found it interesting that we could both use the same word to convey such a different meaning.

Shertaugh: It's the beauty of irony, I guess -- an elusive concept I've spent the better part of my adult life in search of . . . as Eric will confirm.

Posted by: Dave S. at May 16, 2007 4:38 PM

So did you originally intend ballast to mean "load" or "roughage"? Clearly, those two words do not mean the same thing. It just seems to me that you were so hasty to post a bad comment about Cheney that you not only had a number of misspellings that confused your readers, but you also created a metaphor that used a word that has an alternative definition that means the exact opposite of the meaning you intended to convey.

Posted by: Dave S. at May 17, 2007 11:01 AM