« Michelle Malkin's Denial. | Main | Announcing the IsThatLegal "Name My Book" Contest! »

November 21, 2005

How About "Loyalty Oafs: Bumbling Bureaucrats and Japanese American Loyalty, 1942-1945?" ... Nah.

I
've spent much of the last year researching and writing a new book, and am very nearly finished. I am now at the stage I detest: thinking of a title.

My first book, which was about Japanese American internees who resisted the military draft, was called "Free to Die for their Country"--a title I really love. Naturally, I had nothing to do with it. Somebody at the University of Chicago Press came up with it.

Back in high school and college, I always avoided the dilemma of serious and appropriate titles for my English papers by coming up with dumb puns. (I recall, for example, a paper I wrote in sophomore year of college about somebody-or-other's rather scathing critique of "Jude the Obscure;" I called the paper "No Laurels for Hardy.")

Somehow that sort of thing just won't do at this stage in life, however.

The book is about the government bureaucracies in World War II that ruled on the loyalty or disloyalty of 40,000 individual U.S. citizens of Japanese ancestry.

Suggestions are most welcome.

Posted by Eric at November 21, 2005 7:06 PM

Comments

What occasion did the government have to rule on their loyalty or disloyalty (whatever that means)? I thought that they all got put in concentration camps.

Posted by: Henry at November 21, 2005 8:13 PM

Beginning in early 1943, several government agencies (civilian and military) had a number of reasons to adjudicate the loyalties of individual Japanese Americans. One reason was to permit some internees to leave the camps for jobs in the interior. Another reason was to permit some to join the army. Another reason was to decide which released Japanese Americans could work in plants doing war production. And a final reason was to determine which internees should be more deeply locked up in so-called "segregation."

Posted by: Eric Muller at November 21, 2005 8:28 PM

Here's a phony suggestion that certainly wouldn't pass the test:

- Gov doesn't play dice: Official Positivism Applied to Japanese American Loyalty (1942-1945)

Yet another one for the sake of procrastination :

- Brave New Mold: Classifying Japanese American Loyalty, an American Dystopia (1942-1945)

To both I prefer the 'Bumbling Bureaucrats...' though.

Posted by: Gavlois at November 21, 2005 9:16 PM

Ministry of Demagogy: How America Lost World War II

Demagogy in America: An Object Lesson

Unholy Policies in the Land of the Fear


Posted by: David Marshall at November 21, 2005 9:25 PM

(I recall, for example, a paper I wrote in sophomore year of college about somebody-or-other's rather scathing critique of "Jude the Obscure;" I called the paper "No Laurels for Hardy.")
I alway's wondered what they meant by sophmoric humor. (Which I love.)

How about "Parole Board But No Trial"?

Posted by: Mojo at November 21, 2005 9:26 PM

I once wrote an essay on the topic of the world's greatest invention. I argued for the supremacy of cheese. My title:

Cheese:

A Gouda Idea

Posted by: Michael Benson at November 21, 2005 11:14 PM

"On Your Honor" Seems to me a bit of a pun, but what I mean is that people were using the aegis of the US government (my country, my honor) to rule on the honor of others and those others oaths. Or "Their Loyalty, Your Honor"

Posted by: Chris at November 22, 2005 9:54 AM

I read something in a magazine once that led me to belief that some East Coast Japanese were never interred, or most weren't anyway, just monitored and controlled. The article was about a woman who grew up thinking her mother didn't really love her because the mom didn't go to the kid's sleepaway camp's Family Day. The woman found out later the FBI wouldn't give her mom permission to go there.

Still working on a title

Posted by: serns at November 22, 2005 9:44 PM

Okay, I think my suggestion was lost so here goes a second time. Either Inside The Barbed Wire Fence or Outside The Barbed Wire Fence.
Check out the Haiku:
by Suiko Matsushita
Rain shower from mountain
quietly soaking
barbed wire fence.

Posted by: Zelda1 at November 23, 2005 7:11 AM

Spine title: You Are A Traitor
Subtitle: Taking The Loyalty Test During World War II


Posted by: Dexter Westbrook at November 23, 2005 9:18 AM